A weird single intake was observed in June. What happens if I edit the Youth Rating, both before the preview and after? 11. I "think"* what happens now is that the player rates your player against the player at your club best able to play in that position, (and how good he is in that position rather than how good he is in his best position). 18+ - game time is more important, so if you aren't playing them in first team games at least 15 minutes a game, better to send them on loan to a level where they will get game time. Best position/role. Both of these contribute to the potential for wonderkids and overall good youngsters. Though I guess that's basically life. There are 8 levels of Youth Recruitment, and to see it, you have to go to Club Info, Facilities and you'll see your level of Youth Recruitment at the bottom. I will have a look at that at some point. 6 players at 120+ PA. Before we start getting carried away, let's deal with the real basics 1st. As the club we're experimenting with in Spain is actually Melilla, (who are based on the African mainland), I would expect to see more Africans and certainly more Moroccans, but whether that's incorporated into the game I don't know. A high PA young player with low CA is not likely to get 1st team opportunities, (because he's not good enough right now), so he would probably benefit from going out on loan. You need to be a member in order to leave a comment. 2nd Nationality. Another well known youtuber pushed out a development video a couple of weeks back, where they've done multiple simulations to measure development U18s training and over 18s matches. If you are on twitter then bookmarking this tweet might be of help, (at least until Elon turns the lights out). I'm managing in Portugal and playing Youth Only and now have a B Team playing in the 2nd tier in Portugal. Youth Facilities has 20 levels, but 10 different named sections, (each containing multiple levels). Let's take Beckham as an example because you mentioned him. First intakes are sometimes Golden Gens because the player takes it over and starts making massive improvements, so the new players coming are better. To reflect the real-life transfer window and other changes in the global football world, the new FM23 patch includes all the latest football transfers, loan deals, staff movements, changes to clubs' transfer budgets and their . 1. I can't begin to tell you how beneficial I have found the B Team. What single thing has the biggest impact on the quality of a Youth Intake? Continue with Recommended Cookies. It's very strange. Highest CA 108. Junior Coaching has 20 levels, but 7 different named sections, (6 of which contain multiple levels). [/End rant mode] When you consider that the overall level of the Facilities was 23 compared to 4, this doesn't see like a good investment for this purpose, (but then again, you wouldn't think it would be). 6 players at 150+ PA. I have seen players develop 3 gold star PA and higher, and one of these is a first-team squad player for me now in Darren Brook. However, theres a couple of considerations we need to take into account: Without further ado, heres a table with the approximate dates of intake: In addition to these dates, which correspond to leagues that are playable in-game, we were also able to ascertain Youth Intake Dates for those countries that are not playable, more notably the entirety of African countries bar South Africa, several Central American countries, Asian and Oceanian countries. Regarding this, there are two range of dates that the game seems to use: We werent able to determine if geographical location has anything to do with countries being placed in one or another, but knowing the dates should be enough. -10, -9, -8 etc) and then on the youth intake day the CA/PA is selected within that range. 5. After a short trial period, you will get to decide which newgens will join your academy, and which will have to look for a new club. We will go over everything that we know at 100% certainty will help you get the best youth intake you can hope for. The second way it can affect young players is with his Preferred Formation, Tactical Style, Playing Style and 2nd Preferred Formation. Volante Attack by FM DNA Subscribe FM23 Guides Players I could do 100 or 1,000 but I just don't have the ability/knowledge to automate the reports that this would require. (Perceived CA. The youth intake are generally bad and unfortauntely set in stone. 2. Is there any truth to this or is it just an old FM players tale? The PA result was a little better, coming out on top of both minimum facilities and maximum training groups. After all, a L20 Training Facility is a flippin enormous investment. Press J to jump to the feed. The truth here is that there isn't a 1 size fits all answer, quite simply because there is not only 1 thing that influences player development. 5 players at 150+ PA. Below that I don't understand at all how it works. These were obtained from the game itself and cross-checked between different saves, so were absolutely certain that theyre correct. A golden generation means that the staff in charge of bringing youth into your U18 team thinks there are three or four players from the youth intake that have the potential to feature in the first team in the coming years. That ties in completely with the preview, (which surprises me a little if I'm honest). Highest PA167. As a second point, but also an addendum, when we refer to top clubs, we dont necessarily mean so in terms of quality or reputation, but in terms of Youth Recruitment. We determined at the very start of the thread, that in FM22, Nationalities were static from the point of the Youth Intake Preview and would never change. Date of birth/Age. Will be reading this with great interest. Feel free to comment if you have any predictions on experiments you think I might don in the future or if you were surprised by anything you have seen so far. Why do low rep clubs often seem to get players from Secondary Nations in their Intakes with high PA relative to the rest of the intake? If you aren't playing competitive football by the time you are 23 you should be asking yourself if you are at the right club (imo). Cheers mate. By playing him "up" at a level before he's actually ready, I have advanced his development. I recently saw a Youtube video from [Name redacted], (because this isn't about them), about Youth Intakes and I was absolutely astonished by some of the rubbish that was being spouted. It might be hard-coded in with places that have a high number of FGN-born residents. FM22 Youth Intakes are one o the best parts of football manager. I would be peeved if that didn't make a difference. Attributes Range is 1-20; where the 20 means absolute perfect. The 1st thing I have to do is take over a club and I am using my Ceuta save from 1st April 2029, retiring as Manager, adding a new manager and taking over Melila in the Spanish 4th Tier. It contains a comprehensive list of potential people that are fit for the position based on the exact same values we just went over. FM Mythbusting: Youth Intakes Published on 10 April 2020 One of the most exciting days in the Football Manager calendar is the day when your club's youth intake arrives. In comparison to Man Utd they have rubbish facilities and rubbish staff, but he hasn't swapped playing for Man Utd in the Premier League for playing for Preston in League 2, he's swapped playing for the U19's in the U19's for playing competitive League 2 football against men, so the jump in standard would have been significant. http://bit.ly/buy-fm22Football Manager videos you can learn something from. I can neither confirm nor deny that I absolutely 100% completely agree with you,but this isn't about what you "think" or what I "think", it's about what the results tell us. The staff that can be selected for the entry for Bring youth players into the club and inform you of their development is. What single thing has the biggest impact on the quality of a Youth Intake? For example: Brazil has the highest Youth Rating in the game, so signing young players from brazil makes sense. Each year, the FM community spends countless hours improving every part of their youth setup to get the best youth intakes, but it can still be a tricky thing to master. Passion4FM's NextGen Database will therefore be your source for the next generation of talents and your chance to discover some of the potential wonderkids for Football Manager 2023 - all depending on whether the players listed below will get specific permission to appear in Football Manager 2022 , or whether they are born after 01.09.2005. Training Facilities allowed players at the club to improve, Youth Facilities allowed the Youth players, (not yet through the intake), to improve, Junior Coaching largely impacted on Newgen CA and Youth Recruitment largely impacted on Newgen PA. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. The first thing you need to know is that every country has two fixed hidden attributes. The more leagues you include in your database, the more clubs and leagues that will be included by default. And to do that we simply need to head to Finances, Make Board Request, Networking and Improve Youth Recruitment. Just remember that this is a tiny tiny tiny sample size. I will then post the info on 10 different Intakes all run with how the facilities are in the game as is, and then I will change things using the in game editor, go back and run the intake again, (10 more times) and see what gets thrown up. The truth is that you need to think what you want out of them and when you want it by, and then sort of reverse engineer it backwards so that you give them the development that will get them there. Let's say Brazil (the country with the highest Youth Rating) has the potential to produce 2 S tier players, 3 A tier and 4 B tier and a bunch of other lower tier players. 4. I will add it to the list. Freeze Player Attributes. Is it better to loan players out for match experience? When you decide to upgrade, you can see the cost of upgrading by going to finances and then expenditure. We're looking at 16 players, (16 numbers), we're looking at both CA and PA, (32 numbers), and we're looking at 10 different intakes in each experiment, (320 numbers), so by the laws of probability you would expect somewhere in the region of 32 CA's or PA's to end in a 1 digit, 32 CA's or PA's to end in a 2, 32 CA's or PA's to end in a 3 etc etc etc etc. This "preferred" position will ALWAYS 100% of the time be 1 of the Natural Ability positions. Though to me it seems to have an air of self fulfilling prophecy about it. Giving you the chance to scrutinise your club's youth recruitment, you'll get to see what wonderkids - if any - are on offer to your club. day to find the players you want like last year. Powered by Invision Community. Newgens are completely unique players, rather than replicas of retired players. For example I'm sure there are absolutely LOADS of people who are unaware that Average/Adequate on Junior Coaching is the wrong way round. . Today, Jake takes a look at how you can improve youth intakes in FM2023 so you can. This is simply an error that SI made when these levels were introduced, but for whatever reason they have decided not to correct the order in Junior Coaching. There's a quick and easy way to find this out. We have already clarified that Nationalities are static haven't we? Football manager 2022 offers an extensive search in scouting players. We've won the title in 3 of the last 5 seasons, (finishing 2nd and 6 the other 2 seasons), and sit 5th with 9 games remaining this season. I will just do 1 little thing each time. 8 players at 120+ PA. 19. Your #1 source for wonderkids, tactics, tips, player reviews, guides \u0026 more.In-game generated images \u0026 any other Football Manager related items are registered trademarks and/or copyright material owned by Sports Interactive, or their respective trademark and copyright holders.Don't forget to subscribe, then click the bell icon and select 'All' to get notified of our new Football Manager 2022 videos. That's by no means an exhaustive list, but it gives us a starting point. Now at the end of season 1 after the youth intake, some big clubs are interested in my best players from the youth intake, wich are on a youth contract and i cant do nothing about them leaving. If you see a player you like, you may be able to sign them for free, creating your own factory for talented wonderkids. PCA. The problem then is the level of facilities at the club and if the player will play and if so how often will he play and in what position/role. Even clubs like Ajax, Barcelona and Manchester United famed for their youth system rarely promote 2 or 3 players each year who can consistently feature in their first team. While they remain completely silent about Biereth. In this case it tells me that this "has the potential to be a real golden generation for the club". (Quality of opposition, quality of teammates, facilities, staff etc) If you have high potential but not good enough right this moment. A HoYD with Technical as his playing style will produce players with high Technical attributes. In terms of CA, this group came out the lowest so far, (lower than the minimum facilities where they were all set at 1). In which I've been blessed (from a game point of view) by Arsenal, though also cursed (as a Chelsea fan). 1.5K 53K views 2 months ago FM23 Wonderkids FM23 Youth Intakes are one of the best parts of football manager. We know that there are 16 players in a standard intake although this can be increased by the poaching of players from other clubs, (so if you poached 1 player from another Youth Team/Academy then you would get an intake of 17 players, but at this stage I can't remember/confirm what happens if you are the club who has a player poached. Optimising Youth Intake Most of us look at CA in terms of the stars, but if you can't develop the player from his low CA starting point to his potential PA then the high PA doesn't really mean anything. Youth intake day signals the arrival of 'newgens' - players that were not previously in the game but have been generated and enrolled by SI. 5. Likely more game time, but lower standard of everything else. You're correct though. Total CA/PA for the whole intake is definitely something I will add. Preferred foot. Then my main question around youth intakes and player development has always been the same. So don't worry so much about actual CA and PA, (never mind about PCA and PPA). What influences the Nationality & Secondary Nationality of players? My first ever youth intake on FM22 is a golden generation (im with Fulham) 7 3 Football Sports 3 comments Best Top New Controversial Q&A Add a Comment jiniyoro 1 yr. ago Those letters will keep going down until the youth intake actually comes in. A high PA young player with low CA is not likely to get 1st team opportunities, (because he's not good enough right now), so he would probably benefit from going out on loan. This potential group of players is distributed throughout all clubs in the country, with every club getting a chance to produce any combination of the aforementioned players. Those of you who are paying attention might notice that when it comes to Training Facilities & Youth Facilities, Adequate comes before Average, but when it comes to Junior Coaching ,the order is reversed and Average comes before Adequate. Is there any truth to this or is it just an old FM players tale? Now, pick any youth from the first ones generated and you can get yourself some of the best youth players in the world. If it doesn't give us an exact picture, it should at least give us an indication. Or is that what is best for the player? I was always personally a bit skeptical about this, but if SI make the game then surely they are going to know more than some old bloke who can't even be bothered to run an experiment to prove if what he things is true, is actually true? 16. I plan on just doing 1 single experiment at a time so it shouldn't be too onerous. In the dim and distant past, the roles of facilities were quite specialised. Player names, Nationality, Date of Birth, Position. 6. Like I said though, my understanding in this area is pretty weak so.. further investigation required again. When you purchase There's no statistical information because it's a youtube video and I guess that would be boring, so it's presented as some findings. Deciding who goes in what squad and making sure that there aren't too many players in their position in that squad and that they aren't either too good or not good enough for that squad is tough when you have so many players. It doesn't matter what the numbers are. 14. Is the loan system pushed by the in game engine because its replicating the real world? Just go with your gut, because CA and PA lie! 18. I certainly plan on looking at Nationalities at some point, (but was thinking more along the lines of staff Nationalities & Club Affiliations. Something has caught my eye when posting the 1st few results and when it happened again, (but even more pronounced this time), I decided that it wasn't just my brain playing tricks on me so I would mention it and look at it. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. What happens if I reduce/increase the club reputation both before preview and after? Then SI told us that things had changed and that all the facilities had an equal impact on the production of Newgens and things were no longer as specialised as they had been previously. Plus medical staff to try and ensure my hot prospects are as protected from injury as possible. FM22 Youth Intake Tips | Increase Your Chances of a Golden Generation in Football Manager 22. . It's free and only takes a few seconds. You can leave this for last if you're struggling for money. What happens if I edit the Professional status of the club, both before the preview and after? You can read our section on How to track other teams' Youth Intake to learn more. Also, other factors like facilities in the club, injuries, game time and personality of the players will come into play and influence whether the players realize their potential. The backroom staff are adamant they want Azeez to go out on loan. Henrique Simal. Use these tips to bag yourself a bargain future superstar. What's in a name eh? In terms of player development is there an experiment that we could run that would compare development of players who stayed in the U19's, players who were given a couple/few outings in the 1st Team, and the same player going out on loan at a lower level? Then you open up that inbox message From what I remember seeing elsewhere, on the preview day the range for CA/PA is set for each player (e.g. Then it gets more complicated. It's hard, but try and develop every player to the best of your ability, (or just cull them). This should help to show something like lowering the youth facilities reducing the PA of individual players but if your Youth Recruitment is high, you're still getting the same volume of players coming through, and vice versa, do we care about youth recruitment if we're still getting high individual PA players coming through with regularity. If you are anything like me, you don't take a huge amount of notice of the Youth Intake preview. What happens if I edit the Nation reputation, both before the preview and after? We've already calculated that based on the laws of probability, we should expect to see something like 32 occurrences of this in each section so how many have we got? -10 170-200-95 160-190-9 150-180-85140-170-8 130-160-75 120-150-7 110-140-65 100-130-6 90-120-55 80-110-5 70-100-45 60-90-4 50-80-35 40-70-3 30-60